Reclaim Broken Backlinks Strategy

Broken backlinks are money left on the table. When external sites link to pages that no longer exist on your Shopify store, you're losing valuable SEO authority—link juice that could be driving rankings and traffic. Every broken backlink represents a site that trusts you enough to link, but you're wasting that trust on 404 errors.

This guide shows you how to identify and reclaim broken backlinks to recover lost SEO value.

Why Broken Backlinks Kill Your SEO

Backlinks are currency in SEO. When an authoritative site links to your store, they're passing ranking power. But when that link points to a broken page, the value disappears—Google can't pass authority to a page that doesn't exist.

Unlike internal fix broken links that you control, broken backlinks come from external sources—sites linking to URLs you deleted or changed. These are often high-quality links you earned through content marketing, press coverage, or partnerships.

How to Identify Broken Backlinks

Using Ahrefs Backlink Checker

1. Visit Ahrefs Backlink Checker (free limited version available)
2. Enter your Shopify store's URL
3. Click Check backlinks
4. Review the backlink overview showing referring domains
5. Click Broken backlinks or filter by HTTP code
6. Look for 4xx (not found) and 5xx (server error) responses
7. Export the list for analysis

This shows exactly which external sites are linking to broken pages on your store.

Using Google Search Console

1. Log into Shopify Search Console
2. Go to Links in the left sidebar
3. Click Top linking sites under External links
4. Cross-reference these domains against your fix 404 pages list

Sites linking to your 404 pages are wasting valuable authority.

Advanced Audit with Screaming Frog

For comprehensive analysis:

1. Export your backlink list from Ahrefs or similar tool
2. Open Screaming Frog SEO Spider
3. Go to Mode > List at the top menu
4. Click Upload and import your backlink URLs
5. Start the crawl to check status codes
6. Filter for 4xx and 5xx responses
7. Export the broken backlink report

This gives you the complete picture of which backlinks are broken and where they're coming from.

How to Fix Broken Backlinks

Step 1: Categorize Your Broken Backlinks

Sort broken backlinks by priority:

High Priority: Links from high-authority domains (DR 50+) Medium Priority: Links from relevant industry sites Low Priority: Links from low-quality or irrelevant sources

Focus your effort on high-value broken links first—they deliver the most SEO impact.

Step 2: Restore or Redirect

For each broken backlink, choose the best fix:

Option A - Restore the Page: If the original content was valuable and you deleted it by mistake, restore it at the original URL. This preserves the link perfectly.

Option B - 301 Redirect: If the page is permanently gone, redirect it to the most relevant existing page:

1. Log into Shopify Admin
2. Go to Online Store > Navigation
3. Click URL Redirects
4. Click Create URL redirect
5. Enter the broken URL in Redirect from
6. Enter the target URL in Redirect to
7. Save

Option C - Create New Content: For valuable backlinks to deleted category pages or resources, create new content at that URL rather than redirecting.

Step 3: Update Internal References

After fixing broken backlink destinations:

1. Search your site for internal links to those URLs
2. Update any navigation menus pointing to old URLs
3. Fix product descriptions linking to deleted pages
4. Update blog posts with outdated links

This ensures consistent URL structure across your entire store and complements your fix broken links efforts.

Step 4: Reach Out to Linkers (Optional)

For extremely valuable broken backlinks:

1. Find contact information for the linking site
2. Email them politely about the broken link
3. Provide the new URL where the content lives
4. Thank them for linking to your store

Most sites won't update links manually, but high-value partnerships are worth the outreach effort.

Monitor Your Recovery

After fixing broken backlinks, track recovery:

Week 1-2: Use Shopify Search Console to verify redirects are working and Googlebot is following them successfully.

Week 3-4: Check Ahrefs or your backlink tool to confirm previously broken links now show 301 status codes instead of 404s.

Month 2-3: Monitor rankings for pages that received recovered backlinks. They should improve as Google recalculates authority.

Ongoing: Set monthly reminders to check for new broken backlinks—pages get deleted, URLs change, and new backlinks can break over time.

Prevent Future Broken Backlinks

Careful URL Changes: Before deleting products or pages, check if they have backlinks. If they do, set up redirects first.

Maintain Old Content: Keep valuable content live even if you're not actively promoting it—especially if it has backlinks.

Regular Audits: Monthly backlink health checks catch broken links before they cost you rankings.

Quality Over Quantity: Focus on build authority backlinks from sites that maintain their content rather than pursuing links from unreliable sources.

Also avoid practices that require disavow toxic backlinks—quality links don't break as often and deliver better long-term value.

Most stores have 10-30% of their backlinks pointing to broken pages. That's 10-30% of their SEO authority getting wasted. Reclaiming these broken backlinks is one of the fastest ways to boost rankings without building new links.

Fix your broken backlinks today, and watch your lost authority come flooding back.

Related Guides

Shopify store traffic stuck? You're not alone.

We help Shopify stores rank higher in Google, attract quality traffic, and turn visitors into customers.

Get Free Audit

🚀 Trusted by 500+ Shopify merchants